Disagree With the IRS? How the IRS Appeal Process Works

What Is the IRS Independent Office of Appeals?

The IRS Independent Office of Appeals provides an administrative forum for reviewing qualifying tax disputes independently from the IRS office that made the original determination.

It is part of the IRS, but it operates separately from Examination and Collection functions that make many of the original decisions taxpayers dispute.

The goal is to resolve tax controversies fairly and, when possible, without going to court.

That does not mean Appeals automatically sides with the taxpayer.

An Appeals officer reviews the facts, applicable tax law, the IRS position, and the taxpayer's position.

Depending on the case, Appeals may uphold the IRS position, resolve an issue in the taxpayer's favor, or recommend a compromise when uncertainty in the facts or law supports one.

IRS Appeal Process: 7 Steps to Challenge an IRS Decision

Step 1: Read the IRS Notice and Find Your Appeal Rights

Start with the letter in front of you.

Read it from beginning to end.

Look for:

• What the IRS changed or decided
• Why it made that decision
• Whether the notice provides appeal rights
• The deadline for responding
• Where the response must be sent
• Any forms or documents the IRS wants

Taxpayers generally have the right to a fair and impartial administrative appeal of most IRS decisions, including many penalties.

That does not mean every IRS letter follows the same process.

For many formal written protests, the response period is generally 30 days from the date of the letter offering appeal rights. Other types of cases can have different deadlines.

Use the deadline printed on your actual notice.

Before building an argument, make sure you know what the IRS is asking you to do and when your response is due.

You can review the IRS explanation of your right to appeal an IRS decision in an independent forum.

Step 2: Decide What You Actually Disagree With

Next, get specific.

Maybe you disagree with findings from an IRS audit.

Maybe you believe the IRS used incorrect facts, applied the law incorrectly, or charged a penalty that should not apply.

You may also be dealing with a collection decision or a rejected Offer in Compromise.

These are not all the same type of appeal.

If you agree that the tax liability is correct and your main issue is your ability to pay, disputing the tax assessment itself may not be the right approach. An IRS installment agreement or another payment option may be more relevant.

But there is an important exception to keep in mind.

Even if you agree that you owe the tax, separate Appeals rights can still apply to certain collection actions involving IRS tax liens and levies, seizures, or decisions involving installment agreements.

Depending on the notice, procedures such as Collection Due Process or the Collection Appeals Program may apply.

So there is a difference between disputing the amount of tax and disputing what the IRS is doing to collect it.

Also remember that a rejected Offer in Compromise and a returned offer are not the same thing.

A rejected offer generally comes with a 30-day appeal right. A returned offer generally does not carry the same appeal right.

Read the letter carefully before deciding what procedure applies.

Step 3: Gather the Facts and Records That Support Your Position

Once you know what you are disputing, gather the records that actually support your position.

That might include:

• Tax returns
• Receipts
• Bank records
• Business records
• Contracts
• Correspondence
• Prior IRS notices
• Records related to deductions or income
• Other documents tied directly to the disputed issue

The goal is not to send the IRS every document you own.

The goal is to show why you believe the decision is wrong.

If you believe the IRS used incorrect facts, identify the correct facts and provide records that support them.

If the dispute involves the way tax law was applied, explain why you believe your position is correct.

"I disagree" tells the IRS how you feel.

A useful appeal explains what you believe is wrong and what supports that position.

Step 4: Prepare Your IRS Written Protest

Taxpayers who qualify for Appeals generally need to make the request in writing.

Depending on the type and size of the case, you may need a formal written protest or qualify for a Small Case Request.

A formal protest may require information such as:

• Your name and contact information
• The tax periods involved
• The issues you disagree with
• Facts supporting your position
• The reasons you disagree with the IRS
• Relevant tax law or authority when required
• A required declaration
• Your signature

For certain examination cases, you may qualify for a Small Case Request when the proposed additional tax and penalties for each tax period are $25,000 or less.

Other types of disputes have different procedures.

Collection appeals, rejected Offers in Compromise, and other specialized matters may require different forms or steps.

That is why the instructions in your IRS notice matter.

The IRS provides more detailed guidance on how to prepare an IRS appeal request.

Step 5: Send the Appeal Request to the Correct IRS Office

This is an easy place to make a mistake.

Wanting Appeals to review your case does not normally mean mailing the protest directly to Appeals.

The IRS generally instructs taxpayers to send their written protest to the address on the letter that explains their appeal rights.

The IRS office that made the original determination reviews the protest first.

If that office cannot resolve the disagreement, it forwards the case to Appeals.

The IRS specifically warns that sending a protest directly to Appeals can delay the process and may prevent Appeals from considering the case.

Follow the instructions in your notice.

Keep a complete copy of whatever you submit.

And when possible, keep proof showing when and how you sent it.

Step 6: Prepare for the IRS Appeals Conference

Once Appeals receives and reviews the case, an Appeals employee generally contacts the taxpayer about the next steps.

Conferences may take place by phone, mail, video, or in person.

The process is generally less formal than going to court.

You do not need to prepare a dramatic courtroom speech.

You do need to understand your position.

Be ready to explain:

• What the IRS decided
• What you disagree with
• Which facts support you
• Which records support those facts
• Why you believe the tax treatment should be different

You can represent yourself.

You may also have a qualified representative, such as an attorney, CPA, or enrolled agent, represent you when the applicable IRS representation requirements are met.

Professional help may be worth considering when several tax years, significant amounts, collection actions, or complicated legal issues are involved.

You can review the IRS explanation of what to expect from the Independent Office of Appeals.

Step 7: Review the Outcome and Protect Your Remaining Deadlines

Appeals can reach different outcomes depending on the facts and law.

It may uphold the IRS position.

It may resolve the issue in the taxpayer's favor.

Or it may recommend a compromise when uncertainty in the facts or law supports one.

That does not make Appeals a general tax-debt discount program.

A compromise in Appeals is based on the strength and uncertainty of the tax dispute, not simply on whether the taxpayer wants to pay less.

If Appeals does not resolve the matter, other options may remain depending on the type of case.

That can include court review when the law provides it.

But those rights are not identical in every Appeals program.

For example, the Collection Appeals Program and Collection Due Process procedures have different rules and different rights when a taxpayer disagrees with the result.

Do Not Assume an IRS Appeal Stops Other Deadlines

This is especially important if your notice mentions the U.S. Tax Court.

A statutory notice of deficiency can give a taxpayer the right to challenge proposed additional tax in Tax Court before paying it.

But that right comes with a deadline.

Do not assume that calling the IRS, sending additional records, requesting Appeals, or waiting for someone to respond automatically changes a Tax Court petition deadline.

If your letter gives you a specific court date, treat it seriously.

Do not guess.

What If You Submit New Evidence During Appeals?

You can provide information during the Appeals process.

But if you submit significant new information that the original IRS office did not review, Appeals may send or refer that information back to the originating office.

That may require additional review and can affect how quickly the case moves.

Do not intentionally save your strongest evidence for Appeals because you think it will have more impact later.

If you already have relevant documents, provide them at the appropriate stage.

How Long Does the IRS Appeal Process Take?

There is no single timeline for every Appeals case.

Timing can depend on:

• The type of case
• How complicated the issues are
• The records involved
• Whether additional information is submitted
• IRS workload

Current IRS guidance says that if more than 120 days have passed since you filed your appeal request and you still have not heard from Appeals, contact the Examination or Collection office you worked with last for a status update.

That 120-day guidance is not a deadline for Appeals to finish your case.

It is simply a point at which the IRS says you can check the status if you have not heard from Appeals.

When Should You Consider Professional Help?

Not every disagreement with the IRS requires professional representation.

Some issues are relatively straightforward.

But help from a qualified tax professional may be worth considering when:

• A substantial amount of tax is disputed
• Several tax years are involved
• Important records are missing
• The tax law involved is complicated
• Collection action is underway
• An Offer in Compromise was rejected
• Business tax issues are involved
• A Tax Court deadline is approaching
• You do not understand what the IRS changed

Before deciding how to challenge the IRS, make sure you understand exactly what you are challenging.

Quick IRS Appeal Checklist

If you disagree with an IRS decision:

1. Read the entire notice.
2. Find your appeal rights.
3. Write down the response deadline.
4. Identify exactly what you disagree with.
5. Gather the records supporting your position.
6. Prepare the required protest, request, or form.
7. Send it to the office identified in the notice.
8. Keep copies and proof of submission.
9. Watch any separate court or collection deadlines.
10. Get qualified help if the case is becoming complicated.

Frequently Asked Questions About the IRS Appeal Process

Final Thoughts

If you disagree with an IRS decision, do not start by assuming the decision is final.

Start with the notice.

Find out what the IRS decided, why you believe it is wrong, whether you have appeal rights, and when your response is due.

Then organize the facts and records supporting your position and follow the procedure the IRS gives you.

A good tax argument matters.

So does using the right process to make it.

Disclaimer