You're leaving thousands of dollars on the table every year. Most LLC owners don't understand one critical tax decision that could save them $9,000+ annually. For a company earning $120,000 in profit, the LLC vs S-Corp choice isn't just paperwork. It's the difference between writing a check for $18,360 versus $9,180 in taxes.
The confusion about S-Corp vs LLC is understandable. The tax code treats these structures in ways that defy common sense. This article cuts through the S-Corp and LLC confusion with seven specific differences that directly impact your bottom line. You'll see real dollar examples, understand break-even thresholds, and know exactly when making the election makes financial sense.
What Is an LLC? The Default Choice
How the LLC Structure Gets Taxed
Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) give you legal protection without corporate formalities. When you form an LLC, the IRS doesn't see it as a separate tax entity. They look through the structure and tax you based on ownership. Single-member versions get treated as sole proprietorships, reporting on Schedule C. Multi-member versions become partnerships, filing Form 1065 and issuing K-1s to each owner.
This pass-through taxation sounds simple, and it is. Business profit flows directly to your personal return. You pay income tax at your personal rate. Most small business owners stick with this default treatment.
The Self-Employment Tax Problem
Here's where LLC taxation creates a massive burden. Every dollar of net profit hits you with self-employment tax at 15.3 percent. This covers Social Security (12.4 percent) and Medicare (2.9 percent). There's no way to split income into different categories. Everything gets taxed the same way.
Example Calculation: The math on $100,000 profit: you'll pay $15,300 in self-employment tax before calculating income tax. Many owners see this number for the first time and assume their accountant made an error. The structure simply doesn't provide any mechanism to reduce this burden.
What Is an S-Corp? The Tax Election
Understanding the Difference Between Entity and Tax Status
This trips up nearly everyone. S-Corp isn't a business entity you form with your state. Instead, it's a tax election you make with the IRS. You're telling the federal government to tax your business as a corporation rather than using default rules.
Most commonly, business owners form an LLC for legal protection, then elect S-Corp taxation for tax savings. You file Form 2553 with the IRS to make this election. The form requires all shareholder signatures. You must meet requirements: U.S. citizenship, maximum 100 shareholders, and one class of stock. The IRS processes your election and sends confirmation.
How the Election Changes Your Tax Picture
The election fundamentally changes how the IRS sees your income. You must pay yourself a reasonable salary as a W-2 employee. This salary gets hit with payroll taxes. But the remaining profit comes as distributions that avoid self-employment tax entirely.
Real Numbers Example
Your business earns $120,000. You pay yourself a $60,000 salary (reasonable for your industry). Payroll taxes hit that amount. The remaining $60,000 flows as a distribution that skips the 15.3 percent burden. You've saved $9,180 in taxes.
The 7 Critical Tax Differences
Difference #1: Self-Employment Tax Treatment
This drives most LLC to S-Corp conversions. The LLC structure hits your entire net profit with 15.3 percent self-employment tax. The S-Corp election only applies payroll taxes to salary. Distributions escape this completely.
A consulting business generates $120,000 annually. Under default treatment, you pay $18,360 in self-employment tax. With the election and $60,000 salary, you only pay $9,180. That's $9,180 saved annually, repeating every single year.
Difference #2: Reasonable Compensation Requirement
Default structures have no salary requirement. You can take all profit as owner's draws without running payroll. The election flips this completely. The IRS requires reasonable compensation before taking distributions. This isn't optional. Without proper salary, the IRS reclassifies distributions as wages with penalties and back taxes.
What counts as reasonable? The IRS examines what similar businesses pay for similar work in your area. Industry benchmarks matter. The IRS particularly scrutinizes arrangements where owners pay themselves $30,000 but take $150,000 in distributions.
Difference #3: Payroll Tax Compliance
Default structures keep things simple with quarterly estimated payments. You calculate what you owe, send it four times yearly, and you're done. The election multiplies compliance burden. You must run actual payroll through software or services. You file Form 941 quarterly, prepare W-2s at year-end, and file W-3 summaries.
Budget Consideration: Budget $500 to $2,000 annually for payroll services. One missed deposit creates penalties exceeding what you'd pay a service.
Difference #4: The Break-Even Income Threshold
Not every business benefits from the election. Savings must exceed additional compliance costs. If your business generates under $60,000 profit, stick with default treatment. Between $60,000 and $80,000, run specific numbers. Above $80,000, the election almost always makes financial sense.
Calculate potential benefit: multiply profit by 15.3 percent to find current self-employment tax. Subtract estimated compliance costs (payroll service plus higher tax preparation). Results exceeding $3,000 suggest making the switch makes sense.
Difference #5: Tax Return Complexity and Cost
Default returns stay relatively simple. Single-member entities add Schedule C to Form 1040. Multi-member versions file Form 1065. CPAs charge $300 to $800. The election requires Form 1120-S, significantly more complex. CPA fees jump to $800 to $2,500.
A business earning $70,000 might save $4,000 in self-employment tax but pay $1,500 more in accounting and payroll. Net benefit: $2,500. That's still worth it, but you need the complete picture.
Difference #6: Retirement Plan Contributions
Both structures establish retirement plans, but math differs. Default owners base contributions on self-employment income after tax reduction. Election holders calculate based on W-2 salary. While this might seem disadvantageous, remember you're taking distributions not subject to self-employment tax. Overall benefit usually outweighs slightly reduced retirement contribution room.
Difference #7: Qualified Business Income Deduction
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act created Section 199A, allowing 20 percent deductions on qualified business income. Both structures qualify. The calculation differs slightly. Election holders base deductions on distributions (not salary). Default owners calculate based on net profit after self-employment tax. Both typically provide similar benefits.
Real-World Case: A Digital Marketing Consultant's Decision
Consider a digital marketing consultant in Austin who formed an LLC in 2021 after leaving her corporate job. She specializes in paid search campaigns for healthcare companies. Her business reached $147,000 in net profit during 2024 after deducting business expenses of $28,000 (software subscriptions, contractor payments, home office expenses).
She initially stayed with default LLC taxation because the business was new and revenue was unpredictable. By year three, she had consistent monthly retainer clients and felt confident making projections. Her CPA raised the S-Corp election during their 2024 tax planning meeting.
The Decision Process
She was hesitant about three things. First, she worried about the reasonable salary requirement. Her CPA researched comparable positions using Bureau of Labor Statistics data for marketing managers in Austin. They determined $82,000 fell within the reasonable range for someone with her experience managing six-figure ad budgets.
Second, she questioned whether monthly payroll was worth the hassle. She worked alone from home and the administrative burden seemed excessive. Her CPA recommended Gusto, which automated the entire process for $39 monthly plus $6 per payroll run.
Third, she planned to hire her first employee within 18 months. Her CPA explained she'd need payroll infrastructure anyway, so implementing it now made sense.
The Actual Numbers
Under LLC default treatment for 2024, her tax burden looked like this. Self-employment tax on $147,000 came to $20,770. Federal income tax (after standard deduction and QBI deduction) added approximately $19,200. Total federal tax burden: roughly $39,970.
She elected S-Corp status effective January 1, 2025. Now she pays herself $82,000 as W-2 salary. Employer payroll taxes (Social Security, Medicare, unemployment) cost approximately $6,630 annually. She takes the remaining $65,000 as distributions. Her federal income tax calculation changed slightly, coming to approximately $18,400. Total federal burden: roughly $25,030.
Annual federal tax savings: $14,940. Additional costs include payroll service ($600 annually), higher CPA fees for Form 1120-S ($1,100 instead of $650), and quarterly bookkeeping review ($800). Total additional compliance costs: $2,400.
Net Annual Benefit
After accounting for all additional costs, her net annual savings totaled $12,540. She filed the election in November 2024 to take effect for the 2025 tax year, giving her time to set up payroll infrastructure before year-end.
What She Learned
Three months into the new structure, she noted several unexpected aspects. The payroll automation through Gusto took less time than expected, roughly 15 minutes twice monthly. The psychological shift of receiving a regular paycheck helped separate business and personal finances more clearly. She appreciated having W-2 income when applying for a mortgage refinance in March 2025.
She did face one challenge. Texas requires separate franchise tax reporting for entities taxed as corporations. Her CPA handled this, but she hadn't budgeted for the additional state filing complexity.
When Does the Election Make Sense?
You're a Good Candidate If
You consistently earn net profit above $60,000 annually. Your income stays relatively stable. You're willing to handle payroll compliance or pay someone to manage it. You actively work in the business rather than being a passive investor.
Stick With Default If
Your profit runs under $50,000. Your income varies dramatically. You value simplicity over savings. You're planning to sell soon (capital gains treatment might be more beneficial).
Major Red Flag: The IRS actively targets unreasonably low salaries. A business generating $200,000 while paying the owner $30,000 will almost certainly trigger audit.
How to Make the Switch
File Form 2553 by March 15 for current year effect. Alternatively, file within 2.5 months of formation for immediate treatment. All shareholders must sign. The IRS typically processes within 60 days.
Choose a payroll provider like Gusto or ADP. Determine reasonable salary by researching industry standards. Register for state unemployment insurance. Set up your first payroll run.
File Form 941 quarterly. Prepare and file Form 1120-S annually. Issue yourself W-2 at year-end with W-3 summary. Stay current on deposits to avoid penalties.
Common Mistakes That Cost Thousands
Electing Too Early: Owners get excited and elect when profit only reaches $45,000. They pay $2,000 in compliance while saving $1,200 in taxes. Wait until profit clearly exceeds break-even thresholds.
Setting Salary Too Low: The temptation to minimize salary leads to trouble. IRS case studies show aggressive audits. Penalties, back taxes, and interest quickly eliminate savings. Pay yourself fairly based on industry standards.
Forgetting State Implications: Some states tax distributions even though federal government doesn't. California charges $800 minimum franchise tax. Texas has no state income tax, making benefits even larger. Check your state's specific treatment before making the election.
Pro Tip: You can always elect later. Start with default treatment, grow your business, then elect when profit justifies complexity. This minimizes risk while maximizing benefit.
S-Corp vs LLC, You next Step: Should You Make the Switch?
Quick Decision Matrix
- Under $60,000 profit → Keep default structure
- Between $60,000 and $80,000 → Run detailed numbers
- Over $80,000 → Strongly consider the election
- Passive investors → Stick with default
The election saves thousands annually for established businesses earning solid profit. The tradeoff comes in added complexity and compliance. No single answer fits every owner. Your specific situation determines the right choice. Consult a qualified tax professional who can analyze your numbers and project savings.
Many Texas business owners have made the switch and seen dramatic reductions. Whether you're researching entity structures or ready to change, understanding these seven differences puts you in control of your tax situation.
Ready to Explore Your Options?
If you're considering the S-Corp election or need help navigating IRS compliance, our team at IRSProb.com specializes in tax strategy for business owners. We can analyze your specific situation and help you make the right decision.
Get Your Free Tax AnalysisRelated Resources
Learn more about business tax strategies:
- Closed Business Tax Debt: What to Do When Your Business Closes
- Turn Your Vehicle Into a Business Tax Deduction
- QSBS Tax Benefits: C-Corp vs S-Corp Comparison
- IRS Problem Resolution for Texas Business Owners
- Tax Savings Strategies for 2025
For personalized guidance on S-Corp election and business structure optimization, consult with the tax professionals at IRSProb.com. Visit our business structure guide for additional resources.
