Skip to content 
Tax compliance and responsible management of funds are essential for every business owner, but especially for those who receive government grants. The recent case of Martin Handler, a former CEO of a nonprofit in Brooklyn, New York, illustrates the severe consequences of misappropriating federal funds and committing tax fraud.
Case Overview
Martin Handler was sentenced to 58 months in federal prison for his involvement in tax evasion and misappropriating millions of dollars from the federal Head Start program, a service aimed at supporting early education for underserved children. As the secret controller of Project Social Care Head Start Inc., Handler diverted millions from this program, violating federal rules that mandate these funds be used exclusively for educational purposes, not for personal profit. Over a period from 2017 to 2021, Handler reportedly transferred $4.7 million to a co-conspirator, using funds that were intended for community benefit.
In addition to his activities with Project Social Care Head Start Inc., Handler was also linked to New York City Early Learning Co., which received significant Head Start funding. Unfortunately, some of this funding was misused for personal luxuries, including paying off personal loans and purchasing luxury vehicles for board members—both blatant violations of the intended use of federal grants.
Tax Fraud and Consequences
Handler’s offenses extended beyond fund misappropriation. On his 2021 and 2022 tax returns, he falsely claimed $2 million in charitable contributions, resulting in an underpayment of $740,000 in taxes. This attempt at tax evasion not only added to his legal troubles but also led to a hefty financial penalty.
The court ordered Handler to pay restitution totaling over $1.8 million: $1,156,068.10 to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the IRS, $740,000 specifically to the IRS, and an additional $200,000 fine. After his prison sentence, he will serve three years of supervised release. His punishment underscores the high stakes of dishonesty in both tax filings and grant management.
Key Takeaways for Business Owners
Handler’s case highlights several important lessons for business owners, particularly those who operate in sectors reliant on public funding or charitable contributions:
- Transparency and Accountability in Fund Management
If your business or nonprofit receives government grants, those funds must be used strictly for their designated purpose. Misappropriating grant funds for personal expenses or unauthorized business activities is a direct violation of federal law and can lead to severe penalties, as seen in Handler’s case. Implementing strict oversight, such as regular audits, can help ensure that funds are allocated correctly. - The Importance of Accurate Tax Reporting
Falsely claiming deductions or misrepresenting financials on tax returns might seem tempting, but the IRS has sophisticated methods for detecting fraud. For Handler, falsely claiming charitable contributions led to significant tax underpayment and subsequent restitution. Business owners should work closely with tax professionals to ensure that all deductions and claims on returns are legitimate and well-documented. - Personal Accountability and Board Governance
For leaders who also serve on a board, or those who have close relationships with board members, it’s essential to uphold a clear boundary between personal interests and the organization’s finances. Engaging in unethical practices, such as using company funds for personal expenses or providing luxury benefits to board members, not only damages reputations but can also bring about legal action. - The Heavy Cost of Tax Evasion
Tax evasion carries substantial fines, possible jail time, and the requirement to pay restitution. The IRS and Department of Justice have shown that they pursue such cases rigorously, and business owners found guilty face life-altering penalties. In addition to restitution payments, legal costs, and the loss of professional standing, individuals risk prison sentences and supervised release, as in Handler’s case.
Staying Compliant
For business owners, especially those managing nonprofits or organizations with federal funding, compliance is essential. Regular financial audits, robust internal controls, and collaboration with experienced tax professionals can reduce the risk of unintentional missteps and help maintain transparency.
Conclusion
Handler’s case serves as a cautionary tale. The desire for personal gain at the expense of federal funds and tax compliance resulted in a significant prison sentence and heavy financial penalties. For business owners, this story emphasizes the importance of ethical behavior, compliance with tax laws, and transparency with any public or government-related funding. By following these principles, business owners can avoid the legal pitfalls of non-compliance and instead focus on sustainable and lawful business growth.
